Some details of NEP equity methodology unveiled


Some details of NEP equity methodology unveiled

Beh Lih Yi and Soon Li Tsin
Nov 7, 06 8:22pm

The government has unveiled part of the information in its methodology to
calculate the corporate equity ownership in the wake of a heated public
debate on whether the 30 percent bumiputera share has been reached.

The explanation was made in a five-page statement by Deputy Minister in the
Prime Minister’s Department Abdul Rahman Suliman during his ministerial
winding-up on the Budget 2007 in the Dewan Rakyat this evening.

Abdul Rahman - who told reporters at the Parliament lobby later that his
explanation was in line with the government’s move to reveal the
methodology - said his statement today however represented only “part of the

The statement did not provide any breakdown of figures. He said a detailed
methodology will soon be “discussed and finalised” by the government.

Responding to a barrage of questions from members of parliament on the
matter during the Dewan Rakyat debate, Abdul Rahman said a special committee
had been formed in the drafting of the Ninth Malaysia Plan to determine for
the ‘best methodology’ in calculating the corporate equity ownership.

The special committee involves the Economic Planning Unit (EPU), Companies
Commission of Malaysia (CCM), Securities Commission (SC), Bursa Malaysia and
the government’s investment corporation, Permodalan Nasional Berhad (PNB).

Par value vs market value

In computing the corporate equity ownership, the deputy minister said there
are several main sources of information used, including:

  • Records of a company’s final statement for companies registered with the
    Companies Commission.

  • Information on equity of companies listed on Bursa Malaysia.

  • Information from important bumiputera institutions such as the Pilgrims
    Fund Board, Armed Forces Fund Board and the Malaysian Cooperative
    Development Department.

  • Information on equity of trust agencies such as PNB, Mara, and development
    corporations in various states.

  • Information on unit trust from SC and relevant trust fund management
    companies such as PNB.

  • EPU’s study on corporate ownership through nominee companies.

“The figures on share capital ownership of companies registered with the CCM
is the main and most important information in computing the share capital
ownership according to ethnicity,” explained Abdul Rahman.

On criticisms that the government is using par value in its calculation, the
deputy minister said it is a yardstick that can gives a “complete picture”
on the share capital for the overall corporate sector.

The Parliament has earlier been told that the bumiputera corporate ownership
was 36.6 percent but this was based on 1,000-odd companies listed in Bursa

Abdul Rahman said while market value can also be utilised in the
calculations, it will however be limited to listed companies.

“For companies that are not listed, market value cannot be used because the
market value changes from time to time and it is influenced by factors that
are not necessary reflect the actual share value and companies’
performance,” he added.

Therefore, he said the government’s calculation by using par value is

“However, the government always refined its methodology in calculating the
equity from time to time and is open to advice from any quarter to improve
its calculation,” he noted.

Most nominee firms under non-bumis

Meanwhile, on nominee companies, he said the Companies Commission has
conducted surveys and it “showed that a large portion of the local nominee
companies shares are owned by non-bumiputeras”.

The deputy minister also pointed out that a large portion of government
ownership is in public listed companies.

"Agencies and companies not categorised under any ethnic group but are
considered of government importance are company shares owned by Employees
Provident Fund, Khazanah Holdings as well as share capital under Finance
Ministry Incorporated and others.

“However, equity held by public companies and individuals in GLCs
(government-linked companies) are included in the equity calculations
according to ethnic groups (by effective interest). This group includes part
of the shares in Petronas, Telekom, TNB (Tenaga Nasional), MAS (Malaysia
Airlines) and others,” he added.

He said that the information regarding corporate equity ownership only takes
into account equity wealth owned by Malaysian companies within the country,
not overseas.

A specific study was conducted on strategic asset ownership in urban areas
to provide a more complete picture on wealth ownership in the country.

“The results from that research showed that bumiputera commercial asset
ownership in urban area is less than12 percent compared to the Chinese (72
percent) and Indians (almost 5 percent),” said Abdul Rahman.

UM research dismissed

During his winding-up, Abdul Rahman also dismissed a Universiti Malaya (UM)
research paper which found the 30 percent bumiputera equity ownership had
been reached about a decade ago.

He argued the methodology used in the research led by UM academician Dr M
Fazilah Abdul Samad, only covered public listed companies on the Kuala
Lumpur Stock Exchange, now called Bursa Malaysia.

"It used data that were available on the Bursa Malaysia and it did not
differentiate between the bumiputera ownership and government-owned shares.
Its definition of bumiputera equity include agencies which the government
has interests.

“Therefore, the definition and interpretation used in Dr Fazilah’s research
was not accurate to reflect an actual picture on the bumiputera equity
ownership,” he said.

Fazilah’s research was based on a 10-year analysis of bumiputera equity
ownership between 1988 and 1997 of public listed companies on the KLSE. Its
calculations was based on the par value of the shares.

However, her calculations which showed the bumiputera equity ownership
hitting 33.7 percent in 1997 did not include government-linked companies as
claimed by Abdul Rahman. Fazilah had put the government-held ownership at
9.5 percent in 1997 under another category.

This is the second time the government had shot down findings from studies
which contradicted the official figures of the bumiputera equity ownership
at 18.9 percent.

The government has earlier rejected a study by think-tank Asia Strategy and
Leadership Institute which estimated the bumiputera equity ownership at
about 45 percent, based on market value of some 1,000 listed companies.

I would like to suggest that the government should come out with a specification and complete methodology of calculation. Then every year, they shall input the updated data to get the bumiputera equity ownership. It is ridiculous that NEP policy had been indtroduced for so many years and the government yet to finalise the methodology.

Worse of all, the methodology in calculating it is to be refined time to time and is open to advice. That could result in indefinite confusion and argument. The same set of data could come out with different results. The target seems not achievable until finally the government claims on it.

"The statement did not provide any breakdown of figures. He said a detailed
methodology will soon be “discussed and finalised” by the government. "

How the hell did they come up with the 18.9% if they methodology wasn’t even finalized. Pluck from the air? Main Tembak?